9-11

 

9-11
9-11
by Authors: Noam Chomsky
Released: October, 2001
ISBN: 1583224890
Paperback

Sales Rank: 7,450

List price: $8.95
Our price: $8.95
Book > 9-11 > Customer Reviews:
  Average Customer Rating:

9-11 > Customer Review #1:
Making sense of 9-11.

As we reach the final days of 2001, like many people in the world, Im still trying to make sense of the September 11th terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center. For those unfamiliar with him, Noam Chomsky is a respected philosopher, political commentator, and linguistics professor at MIT. This book is drawn from several interviews he gave in the aftermath of September 11th.

Chomsky does not share the mainstream views on the U. S. "war on terrorism." While he feels outraged by the World Trade Center attacks, Chomsky disagrees with and our governments decision to bomb the innocent, starving civilians of Afghanistan. Violence only results in more violence. Rather, using the Oklahoma City bombing as an analogy, he believes that the perpetrators of the 9-11 attacks should be identified, arrested, and brought to court for their crimes. Like me, many readers will be startled by Chomskys views. For instance, he repeatedly maintains that the U. S. is a leading terrorist country by pointing out that the U. S. is the only country to ever be found guilty of international terrorism by the World Court. Terrorism is wrong, he argues, regardless of who perpetrates it, and we should use 9-11 as an opportunity for insight. This book is recommended for anyone struggling to come to terms with September 11th.

G. Merritt




9-11 > Customer Review #2:
A thoughtfully written best-seller from the left

I am deeply heartened to see that Noam Chomskys small paperback, "9-11", is selling exceptionally well, despite the usual critical reviews from his detractors. Although it was written soon after the events of that date, before all of the relevant facts had emerged, Chomskys sure and articulate grasp of the situation makes for enlightening reading.

Chomsky writes at length about the plight of the innocent, war-torn Afghanis, and about the people of many other countries, like Nicaragua and Haiti, who have been victimized by US policies. Reading his account should give pause to Americans who may be swept up in patriotic flag-waving and the ill-considered, narrow rhetoric of Bush and his advisors like Rumsfeld.

Chomsky takes a world view and strives for an informed, balanced outlook. He writes of the extreme importance of not being intimidated or swayed by hysterical ranting or lies; to stay as closely as possible to the path of truth and honesty, and to acknowledge the human consequences of our acting, or failing to act.

This book is must-reading for all concerned Americans. Highly recommended.




9-11 > Customer Review #3:
Morally bankrupt relativism

Chomsky has made a career out of knee-jerk anti-Americanism by any and all means, and "9/-11" is no exception. In leu of a well-thought out exegesis, we find a jumbled collection of email interviews and remarks. For an issue as serious as this, one would think Chomsky could make an effort at scholarship. But Chomsky, so used to preaching to a loyal choir, has no had to make any scholastic effort for a long time. Moreover, this book is shallow in its understandings of the complex dynamics of the Middle East. Chomsky, having little experience or knowledge in this area, is notably useless as a Middle East commentator or in explaining what motivates jihadi terror. His area of expertise--uncritical blame and Leftist demonization of the US--is likewise not very enlightening. This book is proof that Chomsky can publish almost anything, even some emails, and his loyal fanbase will always buy it. (Although profiting from 9/11 while not contributing much to the discussion strikes me as unethical in and of itself). Overall, I found this book very disappointing.


 
9-11 > Related Products
Media Control: The Spectacular Achievements of Propaganda (Open Media Series) Hegemony or Survival: Americas Quest for Global Dominance (The American Empire Project) Understanding Power: The Indispensable Chomsky Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media Perpetual War for Perpetual Peace Power and Terror: Post 9-11 Talks and Interviews Dreaming War: Blood for Oil and the Cheney-Bush Junta
A Peoples History of the United States : 1492-Present (Perennial Classics)
architect books