A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C.

 

A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C.
A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C.
by Authors: William George Grieve Forrest
Released: March, 1969
ISBN: 0393004813
Paperback

Sales Rank: 105,429

List price: $14.20
Our price: $14.20
Book > A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C. > Customer Reviews:
  Average Customer Rating:

A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C. > Customer Review #1:
a mild defense of a useful book

I feel I ought to give a qualified endorsement of this work, given the tenor of some of the other reviews that have been posted. If your readings in general works on ancient Hellas or ancient Athens have prompted curiosity about the Spartans, this book is a fairly satisfying follow-up. A knowledge of the outline of Spartan history helps, since the narrative of this slim work is so compressed.
The most intriguing aspect of the book is where Forrest departs from the chronological narrative to write at greater length on two of the more vexing questions of Spartan history: 1) the true scope of the Lycurgan (or "Lykurgan," in Forrests annoyingly pedantic spelling) constitution and 2) the number of Spartiates at various points in Spartan history. Forrest exhibits a healthy skepticism for the ancient sources (none of which, except for some fragments of poetry, can be said to have been written by the Spartans themselves), although he perhaps goes too far in attempting to deflate the myths surrounding the Spartans, which, whether true or not, exercised such a profound influence on ancient writers on republican government.



A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C. > Customer Review #2:
If you only read one book on ancient Sparta...

Make it something else. This book is far too dry for the casual reader to enjoy. I read it with a few others, namely Ernle Bradfords Thermopylae: Battle for the West and The Greco-Persian Wars by Peter Green and it provided a good source of reference, but not much else.

Also of note by Peter Green is Alexander of Macedon and if your just looking for a "quick fix" I suggest Gates of Fire by Steven Pressfield.




A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C. > Customer Review #3:
A quick tour of Spartan history

This is a wonderful book for the person who has a passing interest in ancient Sparta, but is unwilling to spend a whole lot of time doing research on the subject. At just over 150 pages, W.G. Forrest offers a readable and informative text that gets you into Lacedamon, out of Lacedamon and on your way in almost no time at all.

What is surprising about this study is that the author does not hold the Spartans in particularly high regard. This is unusual in that normally, as a rule-of-thumb, historians either write extensively on people / social organizations that they are fervently in favor of, or utterly despise. It is evident that Forrest neither loves nor hates the Laconians; he merely writes about them.

Forrest covers the period of expansion, which is when Sparta exerted its hegemony (forcefully) over Messenia. It is little wonder that the Messenians despised the Spartans, but slaves throughout history have generally not been treated well. I am inclined to cringe at the tacit notion that the Spartans were the only culture in all of history that treated its slave workforce egregiously.

Forrest offers a nice summary of the influence of Lycurgus, but does not articulate very many of his revolutionary ideas. Forrest goes on to explain how the political machinery of Sparta worked, utilizing the Gerousia, ephors and 2 monarchs. For a people who craved simplicity, the political system of Sparta was quite cumbersome. Then again, it was likely that way by design, so that nothing would ever get done. At any rate, Forrest also discusses some different interpretations of the epoch of Lycurgus life and the the dates of his reforms. Much of this, however, will be of only remote interest to the average reader.

The most gripping part of this book, sadly, is about the fall of the civilization. After their decisive defeat at the hands of the Thebans in 371 @ the battle of Leuctria, Sparta sent out a much smaller army to combat their enemy. However, realizing that the situation was hopeless and they were too outnumbered, the army turned around and returned to the homeland.

I have often been fixated on this about-face of a supposedly invincible Spartan army. It was at this juncture in time that group of warriors decided to turn their backs, not only on an empire, but on a way of life. Gone was the doctrine of Leonidas to "stand and fight to the last man, no matter what the circumstances, no matter the number of the enemy." Sparta would never be the same after 371, and it is with haunting detail and clarity that Forrest takes us thru that sad chapter in Greek history.

This book is highly recommended for those who wish to read of the rise and decline of group of brutal warriors who fielded the most fierce armies of the classical age. These were the men who created the boot camp which military forces still use (to varying extents) in the present day.




 
A History of Sparta, 950-192 B.C. > Related Products
The Spartans: The World of the Warrior-Heroes of Ancient Greece, from Utopia to Crisis and Collapse The Spartan Army (Osprey Military Elite Series, 66) Thermopylae: The Battle for the West Plutarch on Sparta (Penguin Classics) Sparta and Lakonia: A Regional History 1300-362 BC Gates of Fire : An Epic Novel of the Battle of Thermopylae Spartan Reflections Spartan Women The Greco-Persian Wars The Peloponnesian War
architect books