A Tour of the Calculus
|
|
|
A Tour of the Calculus
by Authors:
DAVID BERLINSKI
Released: 28 January, 1997
ISBN: 0679747885
Paperback
Sales Rank: 95,011
|
List price:
$14.95
Our price:
$10.47
(You save: $4.48)
|
|
|
|
| Book > A Tour of the Calculus > Customer Reviews: |
|
|
|
|
Average Customer Rating:
A Tour of the Calculus >
Customer Review #1:
A mixed accomplishment...
Being somewhat a mathematical and literary dillitante myself, I looked forward to reading this book. Perhaps my expectation were a bit too high.
Berlinski is writing in an arena where there arre a lot of heavy hitters: James Newmans "The World of Mathematics", Gamows "One, Two, Three, Infinity" and other books, "The Histoty of Pi", and so forth. A number of excellent writers have taken up the challange of presenting important mathematical concepts to a general audience. Berlinskis intent is to impart to the reader a feeling of what the calculus as well as its historical evolution and import. He sets for himself the difficult task of teaching you the calculus while simultaneously entertaining and diverting you. This is not an easy task, and Berlinski is only partially successful at doing so.
The intial half of the book tends to give the mathematics short shrift while the author waxes effusively over an assortment of historical tidbits. Some are fascinating, some merely diverting, but Berlinskis can be a little off-putting. Hes one of those authors who is enamored of italics; every other sentence seems to have a word or phrase italicized in an attempt to emphasize certain notions that he thinks are important. But this is an amateurs technique, as well as a rather annoying affectation. If a thought cannot be conveyed by words alone, attempting to add suggested vocal inflections doesnt help convey the information any better.
The latter half of the book has some good (though brief) explainations of a number of important topics, but theyre too terse to really instructional and too dense to be something the casual reader can look at say oh, I see, and go on.
I suspect the best audience for this book would be a student just beginning the study of calculus, or perhaps a gifted high school student looking for something to inspire him or her to go off in search of more didactic works.
A Tour of the Calculus >
Customer Review #2:
The people who dissed this book
either dont know enough about Calculus or think they do but really dont. I suspect most college math professors dont really understand Calculus either. And the students they teach end up the same way. The prof may know the techniques or even the concepts of it but not the reason why Calculus was invented or the struggle to get it right over two centuries. Or why the Calculus separates the modern age from all that came before including that magnificent age of the Greeks. Let me admit I did not quite get it until I read this book. Had this book been around and had I read it before taking Advanced Calculus my first semester I would not have floundered so badly. And yes at the time I too thought I knew Calculus, having finished off Differential Equations my last semester in high school...And yes dear "Love mathematics, love literature, hate this damn book" a map has everything to do with coordinate systems! Read the book again, slowly...
A Tour of the Calculus >
Customer Review #3:
Love mathematics, love literature, hate this damn book.
Ill put it simply. This is just way too wordy to be of any use in understanding calculus. Im definitely a math person, which is why I felt the need to write a review; I personally dont like people [other reviewers] lumping their assumptions on me. I dont like this book because its a bad book, period. Its not because I belong to some elite little club (keep in mind Berlinski belongs to the same one!) that enjoys symbol mongering an speaking in an incomprehensible language, as some reviewers so wittily put it. His writing style reminds me of everyone Ive ever met that cant keep their mouth shut. Let me explain: the people who, no matter how much theyve just said (and how much you really got it already!), will keep talking just to make sure they get their point across; all the while illuminating the matter for those who dont pay enough attention, and driving the rest of us (like me) completely mad! I can only state a specific example at this time, as its been years since I put this piece of garbage down. When explaining the concept of a coordinate system, the author needlessly digresses into some italicized remarks that only serve to distract the reader from the task at hand (about directions and needing a map and his wife getting upset with him, it hardly matters what it was since it has nothing in the world to do with COORDINATE SYSTEMS!); I found Berlinskis knack for this kind of writing particularly unhelpful in gaining any kind of gut-level understanding of calculus. Read the review "Offensive" by mrkingsford if you really want to know what reading this book is like, to me that reviewer did the best job of showing how bad this book really is. If you like good writing, look elsewhere. If you like good popular mathematics (History of Pi, GEB, 123infinity, What is Mathematics?, About Vectors, etc.) theres nothing here that wont annoy you to death. For some good insights on certain calculus topics, Id recommend that one reads Eli Maors "e: Story of a Number" plus a bunch of other books before reading this pile of self-concious drivel. And yes, its written in english so all of us english speakers can understand it! You cant pick up a mathematics book and not expect to see a few symbols! I must say this as well: like many of the other reviews here, I once considered myself not a math person; for this reason I feel that its important to state that without some kind of exposure to the symbolism of mathematics it is impossible to convey more than an at-best-sketchy idea of what mathematics (even basic algebra, let alone calculus!) is all about. It doesnt take much effort to learn what a few symbols mean, I did it eventually because I wanted to understand and so can anyone else. If youre really interested in understanding what mathematics is then it is going to take some effort on your part; it has everything to do with what you say you can and cannot do! As for this particular author: the only thing I ever read by Berlinski that wasnt quite so annoying was an article in a magazine about Kurt Godel and Albert Einstein, and I think the editors had a lot to do with it!
|
|
A Tour of the Calculus >
Related Products
|
The Advent of the Algorithm: The Idea that Rules the World
|
Newtons Gift: How Sir Isaac Newton Unlocked the System of the World
|
Black Mischief: Language, Life, Logic, Luck-Second Edition
|
Calculus Made Easy
|
Journey Through Genius: The Great Theorems of Mathematics
|
Trigonometric Delights
|
The Mathematical Universe : An Alphabetical Journey Through the Great Proofs, Problems, and Personalities
|
The Complete Idiots Guide to Calculus
|
The HarperCollins Dictionary of Mathematics
|
e: The Story of a Number
|
|
|
|
|